AT&T (T) stock looks totally hated by the market. It still trades sub-$30 per share, not even 10% above its lows back in March. Indeed, it has significantly underperformed the wider market this year. The S&P 500 is now only down around 10% thus far in 2020, which is not too bad, all things considered, but good old AT&T stock is down more than twice that amount.
Since I last covered the stock, we obviously have a tiny bit more information on how badly the current situation is hitting it. For instance, that post mentioned how WarnerMedia looked destined to take a chunky hit given the disappearance of live sport. The company’s 1Q20 numbers – released a couple of weeks ago – confirm that. Overall segmental revenue clocked in at $7,400m, down just over 12% versus 1Q19. Operating profit dropped by a quarter.
The Entertainment business unit, which houses its troubled pay-TV operations, also fared poorly. Revenue for the period came in at $10,500m, around 7% lower than at the same point last year. The company lost just over a million video subscribers in the quarter – not unexpected, but not good either. Operating profit clocked in at $1,300m, around 10% lower than this point last year. The company estimated that the pandemic cost it circa $600m in the first quarter all together.
Coronavirus aside, there is a wider issue at work here: a lot of folks really don’t like management. If you share that view, then focusing on debt reduction and dividends makes sense. I say that because I’m assuming you would not trust them to do anything else with your money! Regardless of that, my view for some time now has been that the stock is so cheap that this strategy can yield good long-term investment returns. Indeed, I have made the same argument countless times now for this ticker.
To pin some more numbers on all of this, let’s just think about the debt load, which stood at circa $164,000m at the end of last quarter in gross terms. It costs the company somewhere in the region of 4.4% to service it annually, as per its most recent 10-K. Here’s the thing. Normalized earnings power ordinarily clocks in at somewhere around the $25,000m per annum mark. Its current level of quarterly distributions – $0.52 per share at last payment – costs it $14,800m on an annual basis. That notionally leaves around $10,000m left over for other purposes.
Imagine the company did nothing but spend the balance on debt reduction for the next five years. If it reduced its debt load by circa $50,000m, then it saves around $2,200m in recurring annual interest expense. That sum is then free to flow down to the pre-tax profit line. Assuming circa 20% tax, we are talking around $1,700m left over for shareholders. Call it 25¢ per share based on 7,125m shares outstanding.
In a nutshell that sums up why I think AT&T stock is so cheap right now. If it does absolutely nothing except the above, then it reports around $3.75 per share in underlying net income five years from now. That requires it to hold its current underlying earnings power steady, though it actually means slipping quite a bit in inflation-adjusted terms. Or put another way, this scenario represents a pretty poor performance.
The stock currently trades at an EV/EBITDA ratio of circa 6.7. Imagine that valuation remains constant over the next five years. Because the company has $50,000m less debt under this scenario, its stock price would need to rise in order to maintain the same enterprise value. Quick math puts the value at around $36.20 per share, while the current share price is around $29.30. That works out to around 25% worth of share price appreciation. Not great, as I make that equivalent to just 4.4% per annum on a compound average basis.
However, we also expect the company to carry on pumping out dividends to stockholders. Now, its annual dividend raise has worked out to exactly a penny per share per quarter for some time now. Let’s assume this carries on for the foreseeable future. I make that worth an extra $3,500m in total out to 2025, which the company covers via its cumulative saved interest expense. If you bought the stock right now, cumulative dividend cash over the next five years would amount to around $11 per share on that basis.
Adding that cash pile to our future share price leaves us north of $47 per share, which I make equivalent to 10% annual returns from today’s stock price. Note that this does not even include the effect of reinvested dividends. Granted, this is all hypothetical, but I think it demonstrates how cheap the stock is right now. It assumes the lowest returning endeavor, which is debt reduction, with zero profit growth except via saved interest expense. It says nothing about stock buybacks (i.e. the company’s actual capital allocation plan), and only assumes earnings power remains stable in nominal terms. All-in-all, I still think the stock represents a good value pick below $30.
If you enjoyed this article and would like to get new posts directly to your inbox, feel free to enter your email address in the sidebar and hit the “subscribe” button. Thank you for reading!